How to Choose a Ceramic Ashtray for Cigars
By Ron’s Cigar Store | Published: 2026-10-27
Category: Buying Guides
Learn how to pick the right ceramic ashtray for your cigars. Compare Montecristo and Romeo y Julieta options based on size, portability, and design.
Quick answer
Choose a ceramic ashtray based on how many cigars you typically smoke at once, where you plan to use it, and whether you prefer a classic or modern look.
Capacity matters: how many cigars do you need to hold?
If you often smoke with a friend or two, a four-cigar ashtray like the Montecristo Open Ashtray gives everyone a designated rest. For solo sessions, a smaller three-cigar or individual ashtray is more practical and takes up less table space.
Shape and stability: triangular vs. round
Triangular ashtrays, such as the Montecristo Triangular 1 Ashtray, offer a distinct look and stable base. Round or open designs may be easier to clean but can tip more easily if bumped. Consider your typical smoking environment—a crowded patio or a quiet den.
Portability: individual vs. multi-cigar ashtrays
If you travel with your cigars or enjoy smoking in different spots, a compact individual ashtray like the Romeo Y Julieta Individual Ashtray is lightweight and easy to pack. Multi-cigar ashtrays are better for a permanent home setup.
Your ashtray decision rules
- Rule 1: Count your smokers: If you usually smoke alone, choose an individual or three-cigar ashtray. For groups of two or more, pick a four-cigar model.
- Rule 2: Match your space: For a dedicated home table, any shape works. For travel or frequent moves, choose a compact individual ashtray.
- Rule 3: Prioritize stability: Triangular or wide-base ashtrays are less likely to tip. Round ashtrays with deep cigar rests are stable if heavy enough. Check the base width and weight before buying if you smoke in a busy area.
Ashtray comparisons
- Montecristo Open Ashtray (4 Cigar): Designed to hold up to four cigars with authentic Siglo construction. Ideal for group smoking sessions or for resting multiple vitolas during a long evening.
Montecristo Open Ashtray (4 Cigar) - Romeo Y Julieta Individual Ashtray: Official Habanos ashtray featuring the Romeo Y Julieta name, individual size perfect for personal or travel use. A compact, portable option for solo smokers who want a reliable ashtray at home or on the go.
Romeo Y Julieta Individual Ashtray
Which ashtray fits you?
Best for
- Solo smokers or travelers: Romeo Y Julieta Individual Ashtray
- Group smokers or home use: Montecristo Open Ashtray (4 Cigar)
Not for
- Those who need a lightweight travel ashtray: Montecristo Open Ashtray is larger and heavier
- Smokers who want modern or novelty shapes: these are classic designs
