Two ashtrays, two different roles
The Partagas Maestra Ashtray and the Just Cigars Black Ashtray both hold ash and rest a cigar, but they answer different questions. The Partagas is an authentic Habanos-brand piece with a specific design identity. The Black Ashtray is a plain, glossy 8 x 5 x 2 inch tray built for everyday use. Which one belongs on your desk depends on whether you care more about brand character or a simple, roomy surface.
What the catalog confirms about each
- Partagas Maestra Ashtray: Authentic Habanos brand ashtray with Partagas Maestra design; catalog price USD 86.25 (comparison price USD 115.00). This is the only supplied evidence of brand and design. It tells you the Partagas is a branded piece, not a generic tray, and the price reflects that positioning.

Partagas Maestra Ashtray - Black Ashtray: Glossy black finish; dimensions 8 inches by 5 inches by 2 inches; catalog price USD 35.20 (comparison price USD 55.00). These are the only confirmed measurements in this comparison. They let you judge whether the Black Ashtray will fit a specific desk or side table.

Black Ashtray
Side by side: what actually differs
The supplied records do not give a size for the Partagas Maestra Ashtray, so any desk-fit decision for that piece is limited to its brand and design description. The Black Ashtray is the only one with confirmed dimensions.
- Brand and design: Partagas Maestra: authentic Habanos brand, Partagas Maestra design. Black Ashtray: Just Cigars brand, glossy black finish, standard model.
- Confirmed size: Black Ashtray: 8” x 5” x 2”. Partagas Maestra: no dimensions supplied in the catalog record.
- Finish: Black Ashtray: glossy black. Partagas Maestra: finish not specified in the supplied facts.
- Catalog price: Partagas Maestra: USD 86.25. Black Ashtray: USD 35.20.
Desk fit: what the 8 x 5 inch footprint tells you
The Black Ashtray’s 8 x 5 inch footprint is the only hard size number in this comparison. Measure your desk or side table before you buy: an 8-inch-long tray needs a clear landing zone, especially if you also keep a drink, lighter, or cutter nearby. The 2-inch height gives it some visual presence, but the glossy black finish keeps it understated.
For the Partagas Maestra, the supplied record does not include dimensions. That is not proof it is large or small; it simply means you cannot confirm desk fit from the catalog alone. If exact footprint matters, the Black Ashtray is the safer choice because its size is documented.
Which one fits your routine
- Choose the Partagas Maestra Ashtray if: You want an authentic Habanos-brand ashtray with Partagas Maestra design and you are comfortable buying without a supplied size specification. It suits a smoker who values the brand piece itself.
- Choose the Black Ashtray if: You need a known 8 x 5 x 2 inch footprint, a glossy black finish that blends in, and a lower catalog price. It is the practical everyday tray in this pair.
- Consider neither if: You need confirmed dimensions for both options or specific care instructions. The supplied records do not include those details for the Partagas, and neither listing includes care steps.
What the listings do not settle
Neither record supplies material, weight, or care instructions. The Partagas listing also does not confirm dimensions, so you cannot compare footprints directly. Treat those as open questions rather than features either ashtray lacks. If you need a documented size before buying, the Black Ashtray is the only one of the two you can measure from the catalog.



