Torch Lighter vs Soft Flame: Which Is Better for Cigars?

Quick Answer

For most cigar smokers, a torch lighter is the better choice because its wind-resistant flames light evenly and can relight quickly. Choose a soft flame like the Zippo Colour if you prefer a gentler, more traditional light that preserves delicate flavors.

Why Torch Flames Win Outdoors

Torch lighters use pressurized butane to create a hot, wind-resistant flame that stays lit even in breezy conditions. That makes them ideal for patios, golf courses, or anywhere the wind kicks up. The Vertigo Stinger Torch Lighter, for example, produces four torch flames and lights up to 12,000 feet, so you can rely on it at altitude or by the water.

Torch flames also burn hotter, which means they can toast the foot of a cigar evenly and relight a cigar without introducing soot or off-flavors. If you smoke outdoors regularly, a torch is the practical choice.

The Case for Soft Flames

Soft flame lighters, like the Zippo Colour, produce a gentle, yellow flame similar to a match. This lower heat is easier on delicate wrappers and can preserve the nuanced flavors of a premium cigar. Many aficionados argue that a soft flame gives a cleaner, more traditional light.

The trade-off is that soft flames are easily blown out by wind. If you smoke mostly indoors or in a sheltered spot, a soft flame can be a satisfying, ritualistic choice. But for outdoor use, you’ll find yourself relighting more often.

Two-Flame Torch: A Balanced Compromise

The Lotus Ambassador Torch Lighter offers two adjustable flames—a middle ground between a single soft flame and a multi-jet torch. It’s wind-resistant and still gives you control over the flame size, making it a versatile option for both indoor and outdoor smoking.

Its single-action ignition and fuel window mean you can check butane levels at a glance, so you’re less likely to run out mid-smoke. If you want the reliability of a torch without the intensity of four flames, this is a smart pick.

Torch vs. Soft Flame: Trade-Offs at a Glance

• Wind Resistance: Torch flames are wind-resistant and stay lit outdoors; soft flames are easily blown out. If you smoke outdoors, choose a torch.
• Flavor Preservation: Soft flames burn cooler and are gentler on delicate wrappers, preserving nuanced flavors. For premium cigars indoors, a soft flame may be better.
• Convenience: Torch lighters relight quickly and evenly; soft flames require more careful positioning and relighting. If you value speed and ease, a torch is more practical.

Lighter Options at Ron’s Cigar Store

• Vertigo Stinger Torch Lighter: Four wind-resistant torch flames and lights up to 12,000 feet. You get a powerful, reliable flame for outdoor smoking, even at high altitudes.

  

• Lotus Ambassador Torch Lighter: Two adjustable torch flames with a fuel window and single-action ignition. You can tailor the flame size to the cigar and easily monitor fuel levels, making it a versatile everyday torch.

  

• Zippo Colour: Classic soft-flame lighter with adjustable flame and Zippo clicking mechanism. It delivers a gentle, traditional light that’s kind to delicate wrappers and ideal for indoor use.

Which Lighter Fits You?

Best for

• Outdoor smokers who need a wind-resistant flame
• Those who want quick, even lighting and relighting

Not ideal for

• Indoor purists who prioritize flavor preservation over convenience
• Smokers of very delicate cigars who prefer a softer touch