Two Single Cigar Ashtrays, Two Different Looks
If you want one ashtray for your own chair, side table or balcony spot, the Cohiba Individual Ashtray Black and the Hoyo de Monterrey Individual Ashtray White are the closest pair in this catalog. Both are described as authentic Habanos accessories, both are individual size for personal use, and both carry a cigar-house name. The real decision comes down to finish, branding and how each one sits in your space.
This individual cigar ashtray comparison sticks to what the product records confirm. Neither listing supplies dimensions, weight or material, so treat those as open questions rather than assume one is larger or heavier.
What Each Ashtray Is Confirmed to Be
- Hoyo de Monterrey Individual Ashtray White: Authentic Habanos ashtray featuring the Hoyo de Monterrey name The Hoyo de Monterrey name is the main identity marker, so the branding is part of what you are buying.

Hoyo de Monterrey Individual Ashtray White - Hoyo de Monterrey Individual Ashtray White: Classic white finish suits any decor White is the visual differentiator here; it reads as neutral and blends into lighter or mixed interiors.
- Cohiba Individual Ashtray Black: Authentic Habanos ashtray, officially licensed for the Cohiba brand The Cohiba listing explicitly confirms official licensing, which matters if brand authenticity is your priority.

Cohiba Individual Ashtray Black - Cohiba Individual Ashtray Black: Black finish complements any cigar lounge or home setup Black is the darker, more lounge-oriented option, useful if your table or chair area already leans dark.
Black vs White: How the Finish Changes the Choice
Finish is the most visible difference between these two single cigar ashtrays, and it drives most of the practical decision.
- Hoyo de Monterrey White: The classic white finish is described as suiting any decor. That makes it the easier match for a bright patio table, a light wood side table or a room where you do not want the ashtray to dominate.
- Cohiba Black: The black finish is described as complementing any cigar lounge or home setup. It is the more understated choice for dark furniture, leather chairs or a dedicated smoking corner.
- Branding: The Hoyo de Monterrey ashtray features the Hoyo de Monterrey name. The Cohiba ashtray carries the Cohiba brand under an official license. Choose the name you actually want on your table, not just the color.
Size and Use: What the Listings Confirm
- Hoyo de Monterrey Individual Ashtray White: Individual size for personal use This is a one-person ashtray, so it suits a personal chair or side table rather than a shared coffee table.
- Cohiba Individual Ashtray Black: Individual size, perfect for personal use at your favorite smoking spot The Cohiba is also a single-smoker format, so neither option is a multi-person centerpiece.
- Cohiba Individual Ashtray Black: Ideal gift for Cohiba enthusiasts or cigar aficionados The listing positions the Cohiba as a gift candidate, which may matter if you are buying for someone else.
What the Catalog Does Not Tell You
Neither record supplies dimensions, weight, material or a capacity count beyond individual size. That means you cannot compare them on bowl width, rest notches or how many cigars they hold from the supplied information. If those details are essential, ask before ordering rather than inferring them from the photos.
No care, cleaning or safety instructions are included in either listing. Do not assume a specific cleaning method or heat resistance; follow whatever documentation arrives with the ashtray.
How to Decide for Your Table
- Match the finish to your furniture: Choose the white Hoyo de Monterrey for light tables and bright rooms; choose the black Cohiba for dark wood, leather or a lounge-style setup.
- Pick the brand you want displayed: The Hoyo de Monterrey name and the officially licensed Cohiba branding are the two identity choices. Neither is more authentic than the other based on the records.
- Check the price against the comparison price: The Hoyo de Monterrey is listed at USD 51.85 against a USD 85.00 comparison price; the Cohiba is USD 63.92 against USD 94.00. Both show a gap, so weigh the finish and branding you prefer against the difference.
- Buying as a gift?: The Cohiba listing explicitly calls it an ideal gift for Cohiba enthusiasts. The Hoyo de Monterrey listing does not make a gift claim, so factor that in if presentation matters.



