Siglo Finger Cases vs Sikarlan Brown Metal Top: Which Case?
By Ron’s Cigar Store | Published: 2026-11-01
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Siglo Finger Cases and Sikarlan Brown Metal Top Cigar Case on capacity, materials, and included extras to choose the right cigar case for your carry style.
Quick answer
Choose the Sikarlan Brown Metal Top Cigar Case if you want a cedar-lined case with a built-in cutter for three Toro cigars at a lower price. Choose the Siglo Finger Cases if you prefer a slim, alligator-finish finger case that carries three cigars without a cutter.
Capacity and cigar size: both hold three, but only one names a size
Both cases hold up to three cigars, so capacity alone does not decide it. The Sikarlan case specifies Toro-size cigars, which tells you it is built around a longer, thicker format. The Siglo Finger Cases do not list a maximum ring gauge or length, so if you usually smoke robustos, lanceros, or figurados, check the internal dimensions before buying—or treat the lack of a stated size as a sign to ask the store directly.
Materials and protection: cedar lining vs alligator finish
The Sikarlan pairs a brown leather exterior with a chrome metal top and a Spanish cedar lining. The cedar does more than add aroma: it helps maintain proper humidity inside the case, which matters if your cigars will sit in the case for a full day or longer. The Siglo Finger Cases use a red alligator finish and are described as a classic finger case, with no lining material listed. That does not mean they lack protection, but you are choosing a slimmer, style-forward shell rather than a cedar-lined environment.
The cutter question: convenience vs a dedicated cutter
The Sikarlan includes a metal straight cutter, so you can clip a cigar without packing a separate tool. That is handy for short trips or when you want one less item in your pocket. The Siglo Finger Cases do not include a cutter, so you will need to carry your own. If you already have a cutter you trust, the Siglo’s lack of one is not a drawback—it keeps the case slim. If you are building a travel kit from scratch, the Sikarlan’s included cutter saves you a purchase.
Key trade-offs
- Price vs finish: The Sikarlan is priced at USD 39.57 (compared to USD 59.95), while the Siglo Finger Cases are USD 221.26 (compared to USD 299.00). The Siglo costs more for its alligator finish and brand; the Sikarlan puts more of your budget into cedar lining and a cutter. Decide whether the exterior finish or the internal environment matters more to you.
- Cedar lining vs slim profile: The Sikarlan’s Spanish cedar lining supports humidity but adds bulk. The Siglo’s finger-case design is slimmer for pocket carry, but it does not list a lining material, so it may not buffer humidity the same way. If you carry cigars for more than a few hours, prioritize the cedar-lined option.
- Included cutter vs your own: The Sikarlan includes a metal straight cutter; the Siglo does not. If you already carry a cutter, the Siglo’s omission is neutral. If not, factor the cost of a cutter into the Siglo’s higher price. Add the price of a cutter to the Siglo if you do not own one.
Product facts
- Sikarlan Brown Metal Top Cigar Case with Cutter: Brown leather exterior with chrome metal top and Spanish cedar lining; holds up to 3 Toro-size cigars and includes a metal straight cutter. The cedar lining helps maintain humidity, and the included cutter means you can trim and carry in one package.
Sikarlan Brown Metal Top Cigar Case with Cutter - Siglo Finger Cases: Red alligator-finish finger case designed to hold three cigars securely; no cutter or lining material listed. It offers a slim, distinctive carry option, but you will need to supply your own cutter and confirm it fits your cigar size.
Siglo Finger Cases
Which case fits your carry style
Best for
- Smokers who want a cedar-lined case with a cutter included for Toro-size cigars
- Buyers who prefer a lower upfront price and a classic leather-and-metal look
Not for
- Smokers who need a slim finger case for pocket carry and already own a cutter
- Buyers who want a distinctive alligator finish and are willing to pay for it
